I guess I am the nominating committee.
I will put the songs I think are most stink-worthy (culled from the songs you put in the original post) in the comments and you can upvote the stinkiest.
This is probably only round one, because I know people are going to put more horrendous songs in the comments below.
Keep in mind, it’s best to stick to songs most people know. We are in search of POPULAR songs that are terrible.
Island Girl – Elton John
YMCA – The Village People
That Cat Song by Mark Steyn
Crocodile Rock – Elton John
Kokomo- The Beach Boys
Brand New Key – Melanie
Imagine – John Lennon
Muskrat Love – Captain and Tenille
Don’t Worry, Be Happy – Bobby McFerrin
Ebony and Ivory – Stevie Wonder and Paul McCartney
Watching Scotty Grow- Bobby Goldsboro
Disco Duck – Rick Dees
We Built This City – Jefferson Starship
Wildfire – Michael Martin Murphey
Tiptoe Thru the Tulips – Tiny Tim
Hocus Pocus – Focus
Escape (The Pinã Colada Song) – Rupert Holmes
Drop Kick Me Jesus Through The Goal Posts Of Life – Bobby Bare
Feel Like I’m Fixin to Die Rag – Country Joe and the Fish
Keep in mind, only the song with the most upvotes(out of the ones above this comment) will win.
Other songs mentioned below this one will be considered for round two.
ANYTHING labeled (c)RAP! 🤮
Precious and Few by Climax.
Those Were The Days My Friend – Mary Hopkin
Physical – Olivia Newton John
Rainy Days & Mondays – The Carpenters
My Valentine – Paul McCartney
Grandma got run over by a reindeer
“…Precious and Few by Climax…”
Oh Wyatt, you are so insensitive. That is a lovvvvely song. 🤢
Pass the dutchie
9 to 5 by the lady with the big boom booms…
Ok, after seeing all of these HATE song you are all definitely a part of “They are coming to take me away”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tnPG1v61AEk
God Bless us all!
“The Morning After” by Maureen McGovern, from the movie “The Poseidon Adventure”
All Rap which is NOT MUSIC!
In the broad sense of “music”: The entire decade of Heroine induced SHIT from the 90’s leading with Nirvana and all the depressing copycat junkies that have not yet served society justly by .357 magnuming their brains all over the basement.
On the same theme as Claudia:
My Heart Will Go On – Celine Dion from the movie Titanic.
“Don’t Worry, Be Happy” is forever redeemed b/c of being sung by Big Mouth Billy Bass.
Perhaps the Chipmunks could redeem “Muskrat Love”…or would that be species-ist?
‘You’re Having My Baby” ~ Paul Anka
‘Walk Like A Man’ (Sing Like A Girl) ~ Frankie Vallie & The Four Seasons
‘My Ding-A-Ling’ ~ Chuck Berry
‘Blinded By The Light’ ~ Manfred Mann, Bruce Springsteen
(matter of fact, I could name a whole lot of monotonous, boring pretentious horsecrap from Springsteen; “he’s really deep, ya know?” … yeah, like a huge pile of manure)
… anything from U2 … more pretentious crap … w/ the same guitar riff song after song … for God’s sake … evolve!!! (same w/ REM … no wonder they quit …. ‘shiny happy people’ …. kill me!)
Holy Sheep Shit … I’m on a rant now!
… & I haven’t even got to Bowie, The Carpenters, The Who, Floyd, Bread, CSNY, Zimmerman …. gaaaaaaah
I’m a Barbie girl ….uuuugh
It’s bananas ….
Bruce Springsteen We Take Care of Our Own
Don’t know the name of the song but the lyrics are like “Hey little girl is your daddy home … I got a burning desire OH I’m on fire ” what kinda sick pervert writes and or plays these songs? creeps me out
I can’t believe no one nominated Wedding Bell Blues (Marry me Bill) by the 5th Dimension.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEbJLWd-UU8
🙁
TWO threads about spoiled milk and how we should all smell it.
Typical.
I’m not posting any bad music. I wouldn’t make any of you smell spoiled milk either.
Hey Jude (an eternity of “La-da-da-la-di-da-da”)
Damn, now it’s stuck in my head and replacing it from this list isn’t helping.
Black Betty
Ram Jam
That song (Whitney Houston) sung at every wedding in the ’90’s. Hilarious because it was a song about love tragedy and the only thing brides knew was the chorus. Oh, yeah, “I Will Always Love You” (that should be the title, anyway).
And there is a song in which the entire lyrics relies on the words “finger” and “linger”. They should have made it an instrumental piece.
(I missed the first nominating thread):
“Timothy” (where on earth did you go?). I don’t know the “band”. Awful. A song about men trapped in a mine who eat one of their companions. You’d think they’d know what happened to Timothy, right? LOL! Awful!
That hit from 2008 The Obama song.
Hey now @BFH – Daryl Dragon went to my jr high and high schools! His brother Dennis too, co-founder of the Surf Punks. 🙂
@Mary – I think anything getting play time on Dr. Demento deserves a separate consideration.
How about anything ‘sung’ by Shatner?
I Am Woman , Hellen Redy ( I hate that song)
Indian Love Call – Slim Whitman
(or anything else by him)
It would be funny if someone made an album of the top 10 or 12 highest voted songs. I’d buy one to give away as a joke present.
Roxanne – Sting
(can’t hit the station change button fast enough)
Abigail Adams: To thy was done by a group called The Buoys. It was written by Rupert Holmes (of the Pina Colada Song fame). His intention was to write a song that would get banned by many radio stations.
He succeeded.
But if that is a downer of a song, how about Mack The Knife? I knew that song was I was really young. Years later I listened closely to the words. An ode to a murderer????
Desperado: The Eagles or anyone else that recorded it.
The pina colada song (Escape) by Rupert Holmes.
OK Fur, you just KNOW that we must have a “wonderful songs” thread after the #1 horrible song is sussed.
I have about 3,852 to submit…
Not sure if it has been suggested for worse songs but:
“We Are Family” by Sister Sledge
Jack & Dianne
John Cougar Mellancamp
Barf!
*I love some JCM songs BTW…
Giving due props to Canadian Content:
Bondi Junction by Peter Foldy https://youtu.be/tzmU0i0oHHU
I heard an old aircheck from CHUM where the jock said that song was going in the garbage can when it was no longer a hit.
And if you liked Hey Jude, you will love Fly Little While Dove by the Bells https://youtu.be/hIVlW3TAj9g
In the first 1:40 the chorus is done twice. It is then repeated from 1:40 until the end of the song (over three minutes twenty seconds later). At least I doubt the Beatles had any illusions of being profound with the na na na na na na na’s in Hey Jude.
See what happens when the government tries to help out the entertainment industry? It is generally acknowledged that a Canadian “artist’s” success in the US is inversely proportional to that “artist’s” chances of winning a Juno award unless the artist has earned legendary status.
CanCon was implemented in 1971. There are plenty of Canada-only hits from before that that I like.
LBS: the only JCM song I like is Cherry Bomb.
No More Lonely Nights- paul mccartney
Morning Train-
Sheena Easton
Anything screeched by Yoko Ono
MacArthur Park
Ebony and Ivory was mentioned, but no one brought up “The Girl Is Mine” by Paul McCartney and Michael Jackson.
Can we just go ahead and name Paul McCartney to the Hall of Shame? He did some really good stuff, but he also did plenty of awful schlock. Does anyone remember him at the London Olympics? At least his crap was overtaken by the gawd-awful show about the NHS.
Jump Around- house of pain
Anything by carlos santana
“smooth” sounds like every other song he’s done.
Gloria Estefan. All of it.
You know what? Everything from the 1990s. lol
In a similar vein as Timothy is D.O.A. by Bloodrock. About dying in a plane crash.
The worst and longest song in the world is Margaritaville by Jimmy Buffet. We only had a few clear stations, and when they played Margaritaville it was losing a station for half the night.
MJA: Carlos is repetitive in Smooth. He keeps playing the same lick over and over. Rob Thomas makes that song.
I can’t even hear the other guy! lol. Just Santana and his monotony. Like his other songs.
Kermit: I had a friend who loved that. He played it for me. My reaction was along the lines of OMG. Maybe the Mighty IOTW singers can do a medley of Timothy and D.O.A.
Yeah, right.
Kermit- LOLOL!!!
“…when they played Margaritaville it was losing a station for half the night.”
That’s nothing. Wait til you hear it in a foreign language.
No, on second thought, that would just be plain mean. I hope you never have to go through that. 🤣
I hate Little Jimmy Brown or The 3 Bells by the Browns. It is one of the worst country songs ever.
Every song ever written by Neil Sedaka.
John Lennon’s Imagine is proof we’d have never heard of him if he never met Paul McCartney.
Kinda like david lee roth, if he never met eddie van halen.
Macarena
All night long and/or Hello Lionel Ritchie
The Trashmen- Surfin’ Bird (Bird is the word).
Why do the worst ones stay in your brain all day?
Come on, Man! MacArthur Park. “Someone left the cake out in the rain, it took so long to bake it…arrggg.”
Last Kiss — the original by J Frank Wilson and the Cavaliers. — or am I the only one old enough to remember this one.
In the Year 2525 by Zager and Evans
The Night Chicago Died by Paper lace.
NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA….
I heard my MAMA CRY!!!
Knock 3 times, or anything by Tony Orlando & Dawn
WKRP in Cincinnati – by Richard Cheese
Roky Ericson’s “I Walked With A Zombie Last Night”
I walked with a zombie
I walked with a zombie
I walked with a zombie last night
I walked with a zombie
I walked with a zombie
I walked with a zombie last night
I walked with a zombie
I walked with a zombie
I walked with a zombie last night
I walked with a zombie (he walked with a zombie)
I walked with a zombie (he walked with a zombie)
I walked with a zombie last night
I walked with a zombie (he walked with a zombie)
I walked with a zombie (he walked with a zombie)
I walked with a zombie last night
I walked with a zombie
I walked with a zombie
I walked with a zombie last night
I walked with a zombie
I walked with a zombie
I walked with a zombie last night
Walk walk walk walk walk walk
Pina Colada song
Having My Baby
Did no one nominate that before?
I can’t imagine a worse song with a worse theme
Wild Thing by the Troggs.
We’re those drums or wet cardboard boxes they were playing?
My Everything by the Bee Gees.
Heck alot of anything Bee Gees except some of their Saturday Night Fever stuff.
Honorable mention….
Better Davis EYES by Kim Carnes
Kim Carnes always sounded like she had THROAT Cancer!
This is the brain worm thread. I need elevator music to clear my mind.
Gypsies, tramps and thieves by Cher.
Cher in general.
It’s I’m on Fire seaoh, by Bruce Drunk Driver Springsteen.
Now there’s an image, Bruce on fire in a Jeep.
BRANDY YOURE A FINE GIRL what a good wife you would be….
Any and all Polka music.
Any and all Woke Country Music.
BFH, Imagine is the worst. Followed up by “She’s too fat for me”..
Geez.
For 20 years I thought “Bette Davis Eyes” was sung by Rod Stewart.
izlamo delenda est …
What?
“Seasons in the Sun” by Terry Jacks didn’t make the list?
PROPAGANDA!
@Chicago Deplorable MARCH 22, 2021 AT 9:34 AM
Bette Davis EYES by Kim Carnes
All the girls think she’s a guy
She’s got Marty Feldman eyes
“Ebony and Ivory – Stevie Wonder and Paul McCartney”
When that first came out I thought he was singing
“Felony and Robbery”
I always thot Kim Carnes’ voice sounded like “too many BJs”…
I’m in you
Peter Frampton
It’s a tie between “You Broke My Mood Ring” and “Christmas at K-Mart,” both by Root Boy Slim and the Sex Change Band.
But, they were written to be awful –which is what made them GREAT.
Those were the days: back when we had clubs and concerts and a sense of humor…
Two entries from Gilbert O’Sullivan:
“Alone Again (Naturally)” and
“Clair”
Calling Occupants (of Interplanetary Craft)
Blinded by the Light – Manfred Mann
“Clair” by Gilbert O’Sullivan
I forgot all about “Big Yellow Taxi” Live Version Joan Baez….