“Too many Muslims want to mix mosque and state.”

mosque white house

To This Secular Muslim, Ben Carson Had a Point.

Take it from someone who’s been fighting it her whole adult life: The sad truth is that too many Muslims want to mix mosque and state.
Ben Carson’s blunt remarks about a Muslim president triggered much outrage, even after he partially walked them back. But secular Muslims like me, who reject political Islam, understood what he meant: He doesn’t want a Muslim as president who doesn’t believe in the strict secular separation of mosque and state, so that the laws of the state aren’t at all touched by sharia, or Islamic law derived from the Quran and hadith, the sayings and traditions of prophet Muhammad. Neither do we. We really don’t want a first lady—or a president—in a burka, or face veil.

Carson’s comments underscore a political reality in which Muslim communities, not only in far-flung theocracies like Saudi Arabia and Iran, but also in the United States, still struggle with existential questions about whether Islam is compatible with democracy and secularism. This struggle results in the very real phenomenon of “creeping sharia,” as critics in the West call it (and which some Muslims like to mock as an “Islamophobic” allegation). While the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment states the United States “shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion,” the Quran states that Allah “takes account of every single thing (72:28),” which has led to the divine mandate by leading Muslim scholars to reject secularism, or alamaniya, or the way of the “world,” derived, from the Arabic root for world, alam.

In too many instances, we are seeing an erosion of those boundaries, in part led by some Muslims, increasingly using America’s spirit of religious accommodation and cultural pluralism to challenge rules that most of the rest of America accepts. Many of those incursions have been led by the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), a controversial self-described advocacy group for Muslims that, not surprisingly, called for Carson to step down this week.

For example, when I was a girl in New Jersey in the early 1970s, we took our Muslim holidays off, if we wanted, but didn’t demand the rest of the school take the day off with us. Last week, however, four decades later, New Jersey Muslims stormed out of a Jersey City school board meeting after the school board refused to cancel school at the last minute for the Muslim holiday called “Eid al-Adha,” or “the Feast of Sacrifice,” being celebrated Thursday. CAIR has lobbied public school officials for the change for the sake of “diversity and inclusion.

At the meeting, the local NBC news segment showed an older woman yelling in Arabic that the holiday was her “right,” followed by a young Muslim woman, wearing a headscarf and smiling eerily as she said, “We’re no longer the minority. That’s clear from tonight. We’re going to be the majority soon.”

The thinly veiled threat was as disturbing to me as it might be to other Americans. Unspoken is the sharia ruling that Muslims engage in no work or school on the day of Eid-ul Adha, but, instead, as the prophet Muhammad is quoted as saying in a hadith, “O people of Islam, these are days of eating and drinking.”

More at the Daily Beast.

h/t The Mark Levin Show

16 Comments on “Too many Muslims want to mix mosque and state.”

  1. Friday evening radio show from Mark Levin, he calls Dr. Carson a genius for realizing that no mulsom could serve as president due to the huge conflict islom supremacy and the constitution

  2. Finally! A Muslim tells the truth. Again, they came to America to enjoy the freedoms. If they don’t stand with Americans against radicals of all types, where will they go, next?

  3. “We really don’t want a First Lady……in a burka.”

    Speak for yourself, Bucko. I think Michelle would look absolutely fetching in a garment that afforded maximum coverage.

  4. If that’s what they want they’re always free to go back to the third world, 7th century shit holes they came from. Islam failed them miserably so they escape to a free country, now they want to turn a free country into what they escaped from? GTFO

  5. There is no separation of mosque and state in Islam. Non-believers either must submit/convert, pay a special tax, or die. There is no peaceful coexistence. The LibCong who think they can coexist will be among the first to die. We’ve known this for a long time.

Comments are closed.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!