In a primary process that can explain why we sometimes get the candidate we don’t necessarily love, we have chosen Shirley Cothran, Miss 1975, as the all-time Miss America beauty.
Click to embiggen
Cothran is a fine looking woman, but are we absolutely sure she is the best looking?
Just as an experiment, here is a random Playboy Playmate for the year 1975.
Thumb up your choice in the comments.
Miss America
Playboy Playmate
I remember the first time I bought a a Playboy magazine that was full
nudity. I was so embarrassed I threw it in a dumpster. Never bought one again.
These are all good-looking women to be sure, but I can’t confidently pick one without ass photos.
A Miss America on the street but a Playmate in the bedroom! 🙂
1975 was a good year for Playboy, Penthouse, & OUI.
Way before the internet and video.
It was their heyday, full frontal was now OK to print.
Women were women and didn’t shave to the point that they looked like a child.
She looks 17
We want to marry Miss America and play with the Playmate.
Miss America looks classy.
The Playmate is pretty, but what is her talent?
First full frontal
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pubic_Wars
Cynthia Myers. Look it up.
Can they both make sammiches?
I notice while voting in the Opera browser my vote gets expanded to 5 votes. It only seems to happen to these votes, not “liking” a comment.
I remember that playmate.
Random Playmate looks like pouty jailbait named “Bambi.” I’ll take the fully realized woman that looks like she knows her way around a man. Never did care for trainees.
Shirley fer sure.
Of Course, the Playmates are American Pie past, the Miss America is PC correct for the American Pie Future.
Both of em are waaaaaaaaayyyy over the hill.
Gotcha, Roman. Once they start growin pubic hair, they’re too old. Start to smell funny, too.
Geez! They’re both GIRLS!
AND too old!
Is this a trick question?
😉
When I first saw this Miss America here, I thought she has it all. The charm, the grace, that motherly look, the sex appeal, nurturing, and with that come on look, “What do you need honey?” What a woman.
Whew! Thnk God she is white! Ummm, did say that out loud? Sorry.
1975: Best Miss America AND the year The Tux was born.
Shirley Cothran/ Miss America was 22 years old.
Jill De Vries/Playboy Playmate was……..22 years old.
May I have your autograph?
May I please have your autograph?
Could I have your autogr…. hey, that’s not a pencil !!
And 40 years later… 🙂
http://shirleymissa.com/index.htm
So, do we start the process all over again… with playmates????
Jill is 3 months older than I am and grew up 3 blocks from me.
Damn. I had no idea.
Like a fine vintage.
Funny thing about aging, you can grow up seeing or being with someone, and even after twenty, thirty, forty or more years, his or her body has changed (no doubt, so have you!), but the mind and personality are still there. I had cousin come up to me at a party recently, it was, so strange, as if we picked up the conversation from a good forty years ago.
Yup. My pick to win from the start and i said so from the start. Cuz that’s just how bitchin’ I am. You may kiss my ring now.